Speeches & Interviews
Filter by year
Filter by speaker
Filter by year
Filter by speaker
Keynote Address by Deputy Governor Adnan Zaylani
at INCEIF University's Seminar on Reconstituting Islamic Economics and Finance
Kuala Lumpur | 17 November 2026
‘Towards a Reconstitution of Islamic Economics in Meeting the Challenges of Global Economics and Finance’
It is an honour to address today’s colloquium.
A Pragmatic Reconstitution
The theme of this workshop is certainly not new. Reconstituting economics, in fact is not just a theme for Islamic Economics, but also a thinking that resonates within the field of conventional economics. In class, we’ve been through a few weeks of lectures and we have seen by now, there are many areas, approaches, and assumptions that one can nit-pick, when it comes to mainstream conventional economics, that can be challenged as unrealistic, even false or too simplistic and sometime this has led to conclusions, explanations, predictions and even policy recommendations, that lead us astray. I will not want to repeat these here but just to give acknowledgement that these additional perspectives such as institutional, path dependency, behavioural and many more – are quite intuitive and useful in strengthening or supplementing our mainstream economic analysis, or sometimes, they can act as overlays to explain when the analysis doesn’t quite match up to reality. However, one more acknowledgement that I should make is that whatever one’s criticism of mainstream conventional economics, which has made its presence felt since the 17th century, whether misguided or not, the global economy has indeed seen tremendous progress during these past few centuries.
Even today, we have seen that the global economy, supported by economic policies and conventional finance have brought about improvements in living standards, health and longevity, poverty reduction as well as prosperity. Nonetheless, significant structural frictions remain. Modern economies are grappling with geoeconomic fragmentation, inflationary volatility, growing public and private debt burdens, climate-induced disruptions as well as widening income inequalities that are not confined to differences in income within a country.
If we look closer, we can also see that opportunities are not equitably available to individuals to improve their living standards, as well as the persistent disparities in economic development within communities, and across countries. Whilst economies are still struggling to escape persistent poverty, including in parts of the Muslim world, the question often asked is how to generate more growth. Some take a trickle-down approach, hoping that the broader growth or opportunities created for the few will eventually trickle down to the many. But how long will it take and to what extent will this happen?
These complex challenges force us to ask a fundamental question: Can Islamic economics offer something more meaningful and resilient?
As Muslims, we certainly believe that it should. Islamic economics, with its religious and moral grounding, should lead us to different conceptual, intellectual, institutional setting and policy underpinnings, to serve the purpose of the betterment of society. Is this enough though. And what then, do we mean by 'reconstituting' Islamic economics?
There could be two angles to this. The first is when it comes to economic analysis and policy making. As an example, we can take monetary policy and its conventional or mainstream goals of keeping inflation in check. Notwithstanding that it is an interest rate-based framework, the other aspect to consider are the socio-economic implications. Reining in inflation could mean higher unemployment than otherwise. There is a tradeoff. Does the tradeoff and other policy implications look differently when we adopt an Islamic perspective versus a mainstream perspective? Do policymakers preferences, reaction functions, change or differ between the two? The second is in finance itself. This has a longer history, and much more progress has been made. But, there is unambiguity of certain aspects of finance and trade, has enabled Islamic finance to build more solid foundations and practices, gaining significant traction in theory as well as practice. Nonetheless, this has taken years and decades with much experimentation and sometimes, some redrawing. And this should serve as some guidance towards any movements or efforts in ‘Reconstituting Islamic Economics’.
I would say this calls for a gradual, pragmatic yet progressive approach, one that couples structural innovation with historical continuity and perhaps we should not look to uproot frameworks that are working effectively.
Consider our own Islamic legal heritage: when the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) arrived in Madinah, he did not abolish the pre-existing forward sales contract known as baiʿ salam. Instead, as recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari[1], the Prophet (PBUH) validated and regulated it, stipulating clear parameters for weight, measure, and delivery date to eliminate ambiguity and exploitation. This historical precedent teaches us that pragmatic refinement of functional economic arrangements is an authentic Islamic approach.
And to what ends? Success cannot be defined by aggregate production, consumption and GDP growth alone. In the Islamic paradigm articulated by scholars such as the late Dr. Muhammad Umer Chapra, material growth alone is insufficient. Human progress must be measured through falaḥ, a comprehensive well-being that synthesizes material development with spiritual integrity, social equity, and moral growth.
To realize falaḥ, economic activity must be guided by the higher objectives of Shariah (maqaṣid al-shariah) safeguarding faith (din), the human self (nafs), intellect (ʿaql), posterity (nasl), and wealth (mal).
History offers useful illustrations of this success. Under Caliph Umar Ibn Abdul Aziz, reforms focused not only on managing public finances responsibly, but also the equitable distribution of resources and the protection of vulnerable groups. As Aljedani observes, the reforms sought to direct resources “towards the welfare of its citizens”[2]. The key here is that economic progress should look at how it improves people’s lives, strengthens justice and sustains public trust.
This brings us to a fundamental principle in Islamic economics, which is resources. Resources represent a trust from Allah swt. The Islamic economy applies a moral filter to consumption and investment distinguishing between essential needs (ḍaruriyyat), needs that relieve hardship (ḥajiyyat), and refinements that enhance the quality of life (taḥsiniyyat). The purpose is not to equate such refinements with wasteful spending (israf) and squandering (tab-zeer), but to guide priorities and discourage excess.
Furthermore, this paradigm broadens our understanding of human motivation. The narrow view of economic behaviour presents Homo Economicus as a hypothetical individual driven purely by self-interest and immediate utility. Islamic economics suggest Homo Islamicus[3], an individual concerned with the welfare of others whose choices accounts for both earthly (dunya) outcomes and accountability in the Hereafter (akhirah). This is a normative model of how individuals ought to act, rather than an assumption that they invariably do so. When individuals act with the awareness that human beings are trustees (khalifahs) of Allah's resources, self-interest is naturally tempered by altruism (ihsan) and mutual support.
I am preaching to the converted. Allow me to shift gears and focus on a few topics which, to me, are of strong interest as a policymaker and Islamic finance practitioner.
Re-Linking Real and Monetary Economics
First, let me turn to what I consider a central structural principle in Islamic economics: the inescapable link between the real economy and the monetary economy.
Neoclassical models, which is the most dominant mainstream perspective, and to some degree, variations of neoclassical model have operated under what economists call the 'classical dichotomy', an idea that the real economy and the monetary economy are separate domains.
Under this view, finance is not very relevant and is allowed to operate as an autonomous sector where money is seen as another commodity subject to its own supply and demand. This is despite the fact that every day we undertake transactions denominated in money, exchange money for goods and services, we save in the form of financial assets. The common view is that financial matters are largely overstated. As financial matters are of little importance to the real economy, one can ignore the financial sector and focus economic policy on “real” matters such as production, technology, consumption, investment, trade, and more.
This proved a mistake. Because the financial system was then allowed to accumulate debt and layers of leverage to a degree that became highly vulnerable to shocks. One such shock was the Global Financial Crisis. With banks functioning as intermediaries of credit and essentially money creation, finance enabled activity beyond what was healthy, readily flowing into unproductive speculation and complex derivatives, often generating paper wealth without corresponding gains supported by real economic activity.
Islamic economics offers a different perspective. For example, the late Dr. Muhammad Umer Chapra and Ali al-Jarhi argued that in Islam, monetary expansion should be tied to real economic activity, productive enterprises and asset-back transactions[4].
This view has its parallel among policymakers and practitioners today. The view on current modern money is that it is a “credit relation and promise to pay abstract value”[5] rather than a real asset or commodity. The banking system essentially acts as the economic agent that creates and puts money into circulation via lending and intermediation, and financing plays a key role in facilitating all manners of economic activity. This financing is enabled by the promise of future payments and trust that these promises will be fulfilled. These payments must come from some underlying economic activity. In other words, without the economy there will be no finance, and in the modern world without finance there may be no modern economy either. In yet other words, financial policies matter, and the financial sector matters.
The Great Recession offers a powerful reminder of what can happen when finance becomes too far removed from its underlying assets and the economy. Original subprime mortgages linked to houses, but as they were bundled and transformed into complex financial products, the connection to the underlying assets and the actual risks became less visible, while leverage also increased. When the housing bubble collapsed, these layers of leverage quickly unravelled, turning a housing crisis into a wider financial and economic crisis.
The lesson is that asset-backing alone is not enough. The connection must be meaningful, transparent and grounded in genuine economic value. This is where Islamic finance can offer an important discipline. Through murabahah and ijarah, financing is anchored to identifiable assets and genuine economic activity. Through mudarabah and musyarakah, financiers participate more directly in the risks and returns of an actual enterprise.
Ladies and gentlemen,
This brings me to another question relevant to “reconstitution”, how should we approach the debates on debt versus equity, and form versus substance?
From a practitioner's perspective, these need not be choices between opposing positions. Debt-based financing has a legitimate role in Islamic finance. If we are to also consider that modern money today is based on transferable credit or liabilities created within the financial system, it is difficult not to see that debt plays a central role in the modern financial system. The call to expand risk-sharing is not a call to replace debt-based instruments, but to broaden the range of solutions for activities and customers of Islamic banks whose needs may be better served by partnership or investment-based arrangements.
Equally, form and substance are complementary. Contractual form safeguards Shariah validity, rights and obligations. Substance asks whether a compliant arrangement is selected and applied in a way that serves its intended purpose and creates meaningful value. It does not override the requirements of a valid contract and reminds us to look beyond the visible form of a transaction to the relationships and obligations it creates.
The practical questions, then, concern behaviour, incentives and institutions. Are risks understood and appropriately allocated? Do institutions have the capabilities, information and governance to manage them? Can the solution meet a genuine customer need, remain commercially viable and support productive activity? These are the conditions under which a wider range of Shariah contracts can make a meaningful contribution.
Evolving Mindsets for Modern Islamic Finance
The discussion so far has touched on the conceptual and perhaps theoretical perspectives for this theme. Now, allow me to briefly share several reflections from a practitioner perspective on how Islamic finance may continue to evolve in response to contemporary challenges and opportunities.
First, Shariah compliance should be viewed not merely as a legal requirement, but as a foundation for achieving meaningful socio-economic outcomes. The industry's early development understandably concentrated on establishing robust Shariah-compliant contractual frameworks and ensuring that legal contracts were valid and free of explicit riba or gharar.
While legal validity is indispensable, focusing purely on contractual mechanics risks overlooking the broader purpose of Shariah. The broader evolution we must embrace is aligning financial intermediation with the principles of Value-Based Intermediation (VBI), ensuring that finance generates sustainable value and delivers tangible benefits for society, the economy, and the environment.
Second, the future narrative of Islamic banking should be defined not by the scale of financing extended, but by its contribution to productive capacity and broad-based prosperity.
From a policymaker’s perspective, financial growth is meaningful only when it fuels real economic capacity. Our reflection should shift from asking 'How much financing did we originate?' to asking 'What productive capacity did we create?'. Our measure of success should therefore shift to the quality of outcomes achieved, including stronger small and medium enterprises (SMEs), sustainable agriculture, green technology, and job creation.
Third, there is immense potential in moving from fragmented financial instruments to integrated, coordinated pathways. While Islamic banking and Islamic social finance institutions have historically operated through distinct channels, a more coordinated approach offers significant potential to advance inclusion, resilience, and shared prosperity.
Initiatives such as Bank Negara Malaysia's i-TEKAD illustrate how social finance can be mobilised alongside commercial financing and entrepreneurship to support and create sustainable pathways for economic participation and upward mobility.
Finally, the next phase of Islamic finance calls for an innovative shift from product adaptation towards purposeful, needs-driven innovation, underpinned by robust evidence and sound policy foundations. Existing structures have played an important role in supporting the industry's growth and development. Looking ahead, however, there is scope to further expand the application of Shariah contracts in ways that address contemporary challenges and opportunities.
This includes exploring a broader range of risk-sharing and equity-based financing solutions tailored to evolving economic needs. Equally important is the role of the academic community in translating normative aspirations into rigorous analytical frameworks and empirically testable models that can inform policy formulation, regulatory design, and real-world implementation.
BNM's Policy Journey & Inspiring Inquiries for Academic Exploration
At Bank Negara Malaysia, this evolution has been reflected in our policy journey. The development of Islamic finance in Malaysia has never been static. In its earlier phases, considerable effort was dedicated to strengthening Shariah compliance and expanding the industry's contractual architecture. These efforts were instrumental in establishing credibility, building market confidence, and supporting the growth of the industry.
As the industry matured, however, the conversation expanded beyond compliance towards broader questions of value, impact, and purpose. This shift can be seen in initiatives such as Value-Based Intermediation (VBI), which encourages financial institutions to deliver sustainable value to the economy, society, and the environment. It is reflected in i-TEKAD, which demonstrates how commercial finance and social finance can be brought together to promote meaningful economic participation and social mobility.
More recently, we have initiatives such as i-CITA and the Shariah Contract Framework that signal a broader ambition to unlock more purposeful applications of Shariah contracts, particularly in areas where innovation, risk-sharing, and real economic impact are most needed.
At the same time, our efforts have extended towards strengthening the foundations of Islamic monetary and financial infrastructure. We have introduced the Malaysia Islamic Overnight Rate, or MYOR-i, represents an important milestone in establishing a transaction-based Islamic benchmark that is more closely aligned with the principles and operational requirements of Islamic finance and it will made mandatory for Islamic banks for the coming year.
Taken together, these developments reflect an important progression: from compliance, to value, to impact, and increasingly, to a deeper exploration of the very foundations of the monetary system itself.
Yet, this journey is far from complete. As Islamic finance continues to evolve, it also presents a rich agenda for inquiry. Many of the important questions arising from the continued evolution of Islamic finance may require rigorous research, empirical evidence, and constructive engagement between industry, policymakers, and academia.
In this regard, allow me to suggest several areas that could be of interest for further exploration by the academic community:
First, risk-sharing and financial resilience: A longstanding proposition of Islamic economics is that equity-based and risk-sharing financing arrangements may contribute to a more resilient financial system. Further research could help deepen our understanding of how such structures impact economic performance at the macro level, besides on how they absorb economic shocks, support business sustainability, and contribute to financial stability across the economic cycle.
Second, strengthening the ecosystem for SME equity financing: While risk-sharing financing continues to hold considerable promise, questions remain regarding the governance arrangements, credit enhancement mechanisms, and institutional support required to make such financing more accessible and scalable for small and medium enterprises.
Third, advancing the measurement of value-based outcomes: As the industry increasingly emphasises impact alongside financial performance, there is a growing need for robust empirical frameworks and standardised metrics that can assess how initiatives such as VBI contribute to inclusive growth, equitable wealth creation, social mobility, and long-term societal well-being.
Fourth, deepening Islamic money markets and risk-management instruments: There remains considerable scope to further develop Islamic money markets and Shariah-compliant instruments for liquidity and risk management. Future research could examine how these markets can become deeper, more liquid and better integrated, while remaining grounded in genuine economic activity. This may include exploring new approaches to Islamic monetary policy transmission, including concepts such as an OPR-i, as well as Islamic hedging and derivative instruments that support legitimate risk management without encouraging excessive speculation.
In my view, Islamic economics and finance already have strong foundations to build upon. I would view the reconstitution of Islamic economics as the continuous process of intellectual renewal, institutional adaptation, and practical experimentation that has been ongoing for some time already. It calls upon us to strengthen the link between finance and the real economy, to embed purpose and values within our institutions, and to develop policy frameworks that are both principled and empirically grounded.
If we can do so and implement successfully, we will not merely advance the practice of Islamic finance. We will contribute to the development of an economy and financial system that is more resilient, more inclusive, and more firmly oriented towards the broader objectives of prosperity, stability, and human well-being, in line with the higher objectives of the Shariah.
Notes
[1] Sahih al-Bukhari (Book 35, Hadith 2240). Sunnah.com. https://sunnah.com/bukhari:2240.
[2] Aljedani, S. M. (2025). The impact of governance and social reform on the welfare of the people during the reign of Caliph Umar Ibn Abdul Aziz (99–101 AH): A historical and cultural study. Journal of Al-Tamaddun, 20(2), 67–81. https://doi.org/10.22452/JAT.vol20no2.5.
[3] Asutay, M. (2007). A political economy approach to Islamic economics: Systemic understanding for an alternative economic system. Kyoto Bulletin of Islamic Area Studies, 1(2), 3–18. “As can be seen Islamic economic system envisages two-dimensional utility function based on the present and the hereafter (due to the accountability axiom) as the reflection of the actions of this world, leading to homo-Islamicus”.
[4] Chapra, M. U. (1985). Towards a just monetary system: A discussion of money, banking and monetary policy in the light of Islamic teachings. The Islamic Foundation. "...should gear its monetary policy to the generation of a growth in money supply which is adequate to finance the potential growth in output over the medium- and long-terms...". Al-Jarhi, M. A. (1985). Towards an Islamic macro model of distribution: A comparative approach. Journal of Research in Islamic Economics, 3(1), 1–29. "the central bank should allow expansion of money supply only to the extent that it is justified by a potential contribution to growth in real balances".
[5] Khairuddin, A., Azmir, M. F. N., Zakaria, S. N. A., & Musa, M. R. (2025). Fundamentals of modern money and its application to central bank digital currency (CBDC): An exploratory Shariah analysis (Bank Negara Malaysia Working Paper No. 3/2025). Bank Negara Malaysia. https://www.bnm.gov.my/documents /20124/826852/ahmad-et-al-2025-wp325.pdf.